Folklore Book Review: The Paper Bag Princess
Folklore
Title: The Paper
Bag Princess
Author: Robert
Munsch
Publisher: Annick Press
Copyright date: February
1, 1992
Number of Pages: 32
pages
Awards: Gold
Award Winner, National Parenting Publications Awards Our Choice List, and
Canadian Children’s Book Centre Silver Birch Express Award Nomination.
Reading Level: Reader
Sr. “I am doing it all by myself”
Generally appropriate for 2nd Grade to 4th
Grade. Books at this level are appropriate for the now confident reader who can
handle more text on the page and more in depth character development.
Lexile: 740L
Genre: Children’s
Literature, Fiction, Folklore
Summary:
Elizabeth, a beautiful princess, is all set to marry Prince
Ronald until a dragon smashes her castle, burns her clothes with his fiery
breath and kidnaps the prince, Ronald. She throws on a large paper bag and sets
off to find the dragon and rescue her cherished prince. What is her plan once
she finds the dragon? What will she do to get her prince back? Is Prince Ronald
the right guy for her?
Academic Purpose:
This book emphasizes folklore and is a great read aloud book
to get students acting in the classroom and understanding the characteristics
of what is a good friend. In the classroom I would ask students the
characteristics of what a good friend is and what a bad friend is. Then, I would
introduce the book, “The Paper Bag Princes”. After reading the story, I would
ask students some comprehension questions to assess their understanding of the
story. The teacher can pick a few quotes from the book that illustrate traits
about a character or two and discuss them with the students.
Then, the students will practice acting like different
characters from the story. The teacher can assign students different character
roles, and to help them get into character the teacher may ask questions such
as, how would they act if you were the Dragon? Prince Ronald? Or Princess
Elizabeth. This is a great way to check for listening comprehension and build
up literacy. Then, for the fun part! Students can create their own paper bag
costume. The teacher also can help them create paper bag crowns for princes and
princesses. Lastly, have the students reenact the story, which will strengthen
the students’ comprehension, language, speaking and listening skills, and
literacy skills.
After role playing, another activity the class could engage
in is storyboard posters. The teacher can divide the class into groups. Each
group can have different sets of pictures from the story. For each picture, the
students will write sentences that summarize what is happening in the story,
using their own words. When students are done they can display their section of
the story on poster board and display them in the classroom. (This lesson may
have to be a two day lesson!)
Rating System:
Categories:
|
5 Stars
|
3 Stars
|
1 Star
|
Comments
|
Style and Language
|
The book anticipates readers’ questions and
uses great word choice for the age targeted. It has linear progression and
communicates its point clearly.
|
The book follows a linear progression, with
some unclear points. The word choice is okay.
|
The book is confusing as it doesn’t follow
a linear progression at all. The vocabulary in the book is either too simple
or too complex for the age group targeted.
|
This book uses great word choice for the
age targeted. There is many vocabulary words such as, expensive, fiery, and
knocker. The books style and language creates a great book for beginning
independent readers. This book communicates its point clearly about a
folklore story and has a linear progression for a storyline.
5
stars
|
Plot and Character Development
|
The plot is in depth and helps to create a
picture in the reader’s mind. The plot is organized having a beginning,
middle, and end. The character development is strong.
|
The plot is okay. The book is organized
with a beginning, middle, and end. The characters are well developed.
|
The book is confusing and doesn’t have a
clear beginning, middle, or end.
|
This book does have a plot, which creates a
picture in the reader’s mind. The plot is organized having a beginning,
middle, and end. The ending is very abrupt, the reader may be looking for more
information. I didn’t enjoy the ending.
3
stars
|
Interest
|
The book holds real life situations which
draw the reader in. The word choice and story hold the reader’s attention.
The book is suitable for the age group targeted.
|
The book holds little interest and draws
the reader in sometimes. The book is suitable for the age group targeted.
|
The book is very boring and doesn’t hold
the reader’s attention. The book is not suitable for the age group targeted.
|
This book definitely holds the reader’s
attention. The illustrations are bright, exciting, and detailed. The book
does such a great job engaging the reader, but at the end the story stops.
3
stars
|
Educational Value
|
The book is relatable to education. The
book can be integrated into other content areas.
|
The book is relatable to education. The
book may need further resources to help connect it to other content areas.
|
The book is not relatable to education
whatsoever. The book is not appropriate to be integrated into other content
areas.
|
This book is relatable to education. This
book teaches about friendships and can also be used for role playing to reach
the standards of speaking and listening.
5
star
|